"Open-Source AI Is Uniquely Dangerous" – AI Ethics Researcher

We critique David Even Harris' views on open-source AI and his policy proposals.

Overview of the Article

Source: Published on the IEEE Spectrum website.

  • About IEEE: A well-respected institution known for advancing technology and science.
  • Author's Credentials: David Even Harris, a scholar at UC Berkeley with a focus on AI ethics, social media, and civic technology.
  • Article's Main Argument: Differentiates between 'secured AI' (like closed-source AI models) and 'unsecured' or open-source AI models, suggesting that open-source AI poses unique dangers.

Critique of the Article's Views

  • Secured vs. Unsecured AI: The article's portrayal of open-source AI as inherently insecure and dangerous.
  • Comparison with the Internet's Rise: Disagreement with the view that open-source AI is the biggest current risk, comparing it to early fears about the internet.
  • Impact of Closed-Source Content: Points out that some of the most damaging content online comes from corporations, not individuals.

Analysis of Proposed AI Regulations

  1. Pause on Unsecured AI Systems: Critique of the impracticality of halting AI development.
  2. AI System Registration and Licensing: Concerns about government interference slowing AI progress.
  3. Liability for Misuse: Disagreement with holding developers legally liable for AI misuse.
  4. Risk Assessment and Audits: Views this as a potential bureaucratic burden that could slow innovation.
  5. Watermarking AI-Generated Content: Considers this reasonable but not currently practical.
  6. Transparency in Training Data: Agrees with the idea of disclosing training data for transparency.
  7. Know Your Customer Procedures: Sees this as unnecessary and potentially restrictive.
  8. Mandatory Incident Disclosure: Views this as bureaucratic, though it comes from a good intention.


  • Final Thoughts: Describes the proposed regulations as unrealistic and out of touch with the industry.

The Airtrain Al Youtube channel

Subscribe now to learn about Large Language Models, stay up to date with Al news, and discover Airtrain Al's product features.

Subscribe now